Art is usually either aesthetically pleasing or
it causes the audience to feel some sort of emotion. Technological advances
allows us to create and view art not only from the outside of the body, but
also the internal body. One way of using the human body for art is through
using MRIs. Marilene Oliver took MRIs and created 3D sculptures (Abbot, S17). Casini
talks about how MRI is seen as a portrait, which is why it can be considered
art because it does require photography (Casini, 88).
MRI Art
(http://www.marileneoliver.com/current_projects/currentprojects.html)
Although I can see using MRIs as a form of art,
plastic surgery crosses the boundary in my opinion. The objective of plastic
surgery used to be mainly for health benefits such as curing someone, but in
popular culture now, it is used for enhancing one’s beauty. To me, art should
be natural. Like Walter Benjamin states, “Even the most perfect reproduction of
a work of art is lacking in one element: its
Presence in time and space, its unique
existence at the place where it happens to be” (Benjamin, 1936). The reasons
for why people use plastic surgery is not an art form because they are
following and creating standards for people to follow. Art is about being
creative and different, not conformity. Orlan goes through several rounds of
plastic surgery to demonstrate how the male artist portrays female beauty. This
is so harmful and stressful on the body that, it does not seem like a form of
art. The more she works on her body, the more disfigured she appears. I also
found it very ironic because in an interview, she says, “my goal was to be
different”, but is she being different if she is taking the most notable body
parts of these female portraits and placing it on herself (Jeffries, 2009).
Plastic Surgery
(http://www.budapestbylocals.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/plastic_sugery.jpg)
Orlan
(https://scarlettgoeswest.wordpress.com/2013/06/24/lost-in-narcissus-mirror/)
As far as medical technology and art going hand
and hand, I think there is a fine line that should not be crossed because it
can become dangerous when used in the wrong ways. Also, I find it debatable
whether some medical technologies really can be used to create art or not
because it defeats the technologies main purpose and as you work and alter a piece more and more, it holds less essence of art.
Works Cited
Abbott, Wynn. "Feature: Medical Interventions—visual
Art Meets Medical Technology." The Lancet 368 (2006): S17-18. Web.
Bejamin, Walter. “The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical
Reproduction.” 1936. Web.
Casini, Silvia. "Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) as
Mirror and Portrait: MRI Configurations between Science and the Arts."
Configurations: 73-99. Web.
Jeffries, Stuart. "Orlan's Art of Sex and
Surgery." The Guardian. The Guardian, 1 July 2009. Web.
"Orlan." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation. Web.
UConlineprogram. “Medicine pt1-pt3.” Youtube. Youtube, 21 April 2012. Web.
I liked your opinion regarding plastic surgery and its harm. It is interesting that you saw how plastic surgery causes conformity, and this conformity causes the loss of art's unique quality. As a result, plastic surgery is no longer artistic. There are also ethical issues that arise when some doctors agree to carry out the surgical procedure on Orlan and are worth debating. How do these issues relating to Orlan compare to the doctors who perform legal but inherently risky plastic surgeries on people just wanting to look beautiful to a standard rather than people who suffered injuries?
ReplyDeleteHamilton Trinh
Personally speaking, I think plastic surgery is definitely a form of arts. It may be risky and harmful to one's health. But those factor can't exclude it from arts. Plastic surgery is just like drawing on one's face by using medical technology. A doctor who performs plastic surgery must be an artist too, otherwise, how can he or she create a beautiful face. This is a perfect example of third culture, indeed
ReplyDeleteAlthough I understand how you point of view on plastic surgery, I would have to agree with Yang in that plastic surgery should be considered an art form. Many of the people that choose to undergo plastic surgery are displeased with their physical appearance, which can be as unhealthy as the surgery itself. The surgery is a form of art because each individual is choosing their own idea of beauty and attempting to emulate that through their own body. With these changes, they are then much more confident and happy with themselves. I agree that there is a standard for beauty and that beauty does converge, but I believe if we took all people that have undergone plastic surgery, we would see individual images of beauty more than one cookie cutter mold.
ReplyDelete